|
The VE Bulletin Excerpts
'No price is too high to pay for the privilege of owning yourself' Rudyard Kipling
Vol 20: No 2 July 2003
Oregon |
Arizona |
Isle of Man |
Luxembourg
World News
Oregon Oregon - Fifth Annual Report on Death with Dignity Act
The Oregon Dept of Human Services has released its Fifth Annual Report concerning the Death with Dignity
Act, which provides for physician-assisted suicide (PAS). The
department's concluding comments were that the number of prescriptions
written, and the number of patients using the prescribed medication
have increased, but they still represent less than 1/8th of
one percent of the total number of deaths. Educated patients are more
likely to choose the option of assisted suicide, and those with college
degrees are generally better informed about end of life choices.
Multiple sclerosis is the most prominent illness leading to requests
for PAS, with one third of these patients discussing that they would
seek this in the last month of life. The department maintains that 'the
availability of PAS may have led to efforts to improve end-of-life care
through other modalities'.
This is of course to be commended, and
should reassure opponents of choice who assert that the availability of
voluntary euthanasia or PAS will have a negative impact on the provision of good palliative care.
Meanwhile
Attorney General John Ashcroft continues his relentless campaign to
override the democratic decision making of Oregonians, validated by two
citizen initiated referenda on physician assisted suicide, by
attempting to outlaw the federal provision of medication for choice in
dying. The words of Barbara Coombs Lee, President of Compassion in
Dying, therefore have a particular resonance. She argues that 'no-one
should have the right - especially John Ashcroft- to take away freedom
to work with your doctor to shape an end to life that honors the
beliefs and values of a lifetime.'
For further information contact the Oregon Dept Human Service Website - www.ohd.hr.state.or.us/chs/pas/ar-disc.cfm
Also refer to SAVES Fact Sheet 18 - Oregon's Doctor Assisted Suicide Law
Julia Anaf
ArizonaArizona USA
Dr Merlin ('Monte') DuVal,
the founding dean of the College of Medicine, is pioneering possibly
the most important advancement for his state's medical profession
through promoting Arizona's Aid in Dying Bill. In testifying
before the House Health Committee, Dr DuVal supports a bill which would
allow terminally ill patients to seek lethal medication through the
assistance of a willing physician. The bill was proposed by Linda
Lopez, Tucson's Democrat representative, with the moral foundation
being expressed in the Declaration of Independence; that one's
own life is man's (sic) fundamental right, and that the political
freedom to live by the consequences of one's own choices is inalienable.
The primary opponents of the bill are the Roman Catholic Church and
other conservative religious groups. The Reverend Van Wagner, vicar
general of the Diocese of Tucson claimed that 'life is a gift from our
creator'. In response Ruthe Steinberg, vice president of the Tucson
Chapter of Arizonans for Death with Dignity, argued that those who
advocate the 'right to life' position demand that individuals sacrifice
their own to God or society. However a free society rejects such
arbitrary claims.
Based on an article by Erik Flesch in the Arizona Daily Wildcat, US 'Aid in Dying celebrates right to life' 27th February 2003.
Isle of ManIsle of Man in voluntary euthanasia bid
The
Isle of Man, with a population of approximately 80,000, is a UK crown
dependency, and is free to introduce certain laws without interference
from the British government. Members of the island's parliament have
voted to set up a committee to investigate the issue of voluntary
euthanasia; spending at least one year hearing evidence from all those
involved in the debate, before drafting possible legislation. Under the
proposed legislation, only those living on the Isle of Man, situated 70
miles off the western coast of England, would be able to die with the
help of a medical professional.
The politicians are adamant that people
living in other parts of the UK would not be able to travel to the
island to receive medical help to die. Any legislation would have to be
approved by the Queen.
Source: BBC News 14May03
LuxembourgLuxembourg reform lost by one vote
In the Luxembourg Parliament on March 12th
2003, a resolution pleading for the decriminalisation of voluntary
euthanasia under specific conditions missed adoption by only one voice,
with 27 votes for and 28 against, with one abstention and 4 absentees.
All 19 members of the ruling Catholic party (in coalition with the
Democrats) voted against the resolution. With the pending election in
June 2004, the Green Party will continue to make law reform for
voluntary euthanasia an ongoing issue for debate.
From the 'World Right-to-Die Newsletter issue number 43, April 200
Previous item |
Back to Newletter Contents |
Next Item
|